Skip to main content

Critic scores

The latest Bordeaux En Primeur 2023 scores

Scores from leading critics

The table below compares the latest Bordeaux En Primeur 2023 critic scores. It will be updated as the campaign unfolds. To view their full reports and tasting notes, please click through and subscribe to the relevant publication. You can find links behind their initials on the top row, or in the key at the bottom of the page.

Liv-ex will be analysing and publishing analyses on all the wines listed in the run up to and throughout the upcoming Bordeaux En Primeur 2023 campaign. For instant email alerts, subscribe here. 

Wine name AG CH Falstaff GH JS JR JA JMQ JD JL LPB MJ NM RS RV WA
Angelus 94-96 96-98 97 – 97-98 – 96 97 93-96 96-98 96-98 – 94-96 96 – 95-96
Armailhac 90-92 91-93 93 – 93-94 – 94 93 92-94 92-94 93-95 – 91-93 92 – 92-93
Ausone 96-98 96-98+ 96 – 98-99 – 97 98 – 97-99 98-100 – 96-98 98 – 95-97
Batailley 90-93 93-95 94 – 95-96 – 96 94 89-91 93-95 93-95 – 93-95 95 – –
Beausejour (Duffau-Lagarrosse) 92-95 98-100 97 – 95-96 – 98 95 93-95 96-98 96-98 – 94-96 – – 96-98
Belair Monange 94-96 96-98+ 97 – 97-98 – 97 97 94-97 95-97 96-98 – 95-97 94 – 94-96
Beychevelle 94-96 94-96 93 – 94-95 – 94 94 93-96 94-96 90-92 – 92-94 95 – 93-94
Branaire Ducru 91-93 93-95 93 – 95-96 – 94 95 93-95 93-95 92-94 – 92-94 92 – 93-94
Brane Cantenac 94-96 96-98 95 – 95-96 – 96 96 95-97 95-97 94-96 – 93-95 94 – 93-95
Calon Segur 94-96 94-96 96 – 96-97 – 97 95 95-98 95-97 95-97 – 92-94 95 – 94-96
Canon (Saint Emilion) 94-96 96-98 96 – 99-100 – 96 97 94-96 97-99 98-100 – 94-96 95 – 96-98
Canon Gaffeliere 94-97 93-95+ 94 – 96-97 – 94 90 92-94+ 95-97 95-97 – 92-94 94 – 90-92
Cantemerle 88-90 92-94 91 – 93-94 – 92 89 88-91 – 83-85 – 87-89 92 – 88-89
Cantenac Brown 93-96 94-96 94 – 95-96 – 94 94 – 94-96 91-92 – 91-93 94 – 93-95
Carmes Haut Brion 94-96 96-98 97 – 98-99 – 96 97 95-97 96-98 96-98 – 94-96 96 – 97-99
Carruades Lafite 92-94 92-94 95 – 95-96 – 94 94 92-94 92-94 92-94 – 91-93 93 – 91-93
Chapelle Mission Haut Brion 90-92 91-93+ 92 – 95-96 – 93 91 91-94 91-93 91-93 – 89-91 92 – 90-92
Chasse Spleen 89-91 89-91 90 – 92-93 – 91 – 85-88 89-91 – – 91-93 92 – 89-91
Cheval Blanc 95-98 98-100 97 – 98-99 – – 98 96-98 97-99 97-99 – 96-98 98 – 98-100
Clarence Haut Brion 91-93 93-95 93 – 95-96 – 94 93 90-92 92-94 91-93 – 90-92 91 – 91-93
Clerc Milon 91-93 93-95 95 – 95-96 – 96 94 92-94 93-95 92-94 – 92-94 92 – 92-94
Clinet 94-96 94-96 93 – 95-96 – 95 94 93-95+ 95-97 95-97 – 93-95 95 – 94-95
Clos Fourtet 94-96 95-97+ 93 – 97-98 – 95 96 94-96 95-97 95-97 – 92-94 94 – 94-96
Clos Marquis 93-95 93-95 – – 95-96 – 94 95 92-94 92-94 89-91 – 91-93 93 – 91-93
Conseillante 95-97 97-99 95 – 97-98 – 97 – 95-97 97-99 97-99 – 96-98 96 – 98-100
Cos d’Estournel 96-98 96-98+ 95 – 98-99 – 97 97 95-97 96-98 95-97 – 94-96 97 – 95-96
Cos d’Estournel Blanc 91-93 93-95 93 – 97-98 – 95 95 95-97 95 93-95 – 92-94 96 – 90-92
Coutet (Barsac) 93-95 93-95+ 93 – 94-95 – 96 94 95-97 95-97 – – 94-96 97 – –
Croix Beaucaillou 90-92 92-94 93 – 94-95 – 93 – 91-93 92-94 91-93 – 91-93 92 – –
Doisy Vedrines 92-94 91-93+ 92 – 93-94 – 94 95 94-96 92-94 – – 93-95 92 – –
Domaine Chevalier 94-96 94-96+ 93 – 97-98 – 95 94 94-96 95-97 94-96 – 94-96 91 – 94-96
Domaine Chevalier Blanc 94-96 95-97 94 – 97-98 – – 94 93-96 95 94-96 – 94-96 90 – 94-96
Ducru Beaucaillou 95-97 95-97+ 96 – 96-97 – 96 – 95-97 96-98 97-97 – 94-96 95 – –
Duhart Milon 92-94 93-95 93 – 94-95 – 95 93 92-94 93-95 93-95 – 93-95 93 – 92-94
Eglise Clinet 94-97 97-99 94 – 97-98 – 97 97 95-97 97-99 97-99 – 98-100 – – 93-95
Evangile 94-96 95-97+ 95 – 96-97 – 96 96 93-95+ 96-98 93-95 – 94-96 94 – 93-95
Figeac 95-98 97-99 97 – 97-98 – 98 96 94-97 97-99 96-98 – 96-98 96 – 96-98
Filhot – – – – – – 94 – – – – – 82-85 92 – –
Fleur Petrus 94-96 95-97+ 95 – 97-98 – 95 97 94-97 96-98 93-95 – 92-94 94 – 94-96
Forts Latour 92-94 92-94 93 – 96-97 – 93 95 91-93 94-96 92-94 – 92-94 92 – 91-93
Gaffeliere 93-96 93-95+ 94 – 94-95 – – 96 94-97 – 96-98 – 94-96 94 – –
Gazin (Pomerol) 91-93 92-94+ 93 – 95-96 – 94 94 91-93 92-94 92-94 – 91-93 – – 88-90
Giscours 96-98 94-96 95 – 96-97 – 95 91 94-96 93-95 93-95 – 90-92 91 – 94-96
Gloria 91-93 90-92+ 92 – 93-94 – 93 92 92-94 91-93 89-91 – 90-92 91 – 90-92
Grand Mayne 92-94 92-94 91 – 92-93 – 93 93 90-92 92-94 93-95 – 92-94 92 – –
Grand Puy Ducasse 93-95 92-94 92 – 93-94 – 93 89 93-95+ 92-94 90-92 – 92-94 90 – 86-88
Grand Puy Lacoste 92-94 93-95 95 – – – 94 96 93-95 93-95 91-93 – 93-95 93 – 93-95
Gruaud Larose 94-96 96-98 94 – – – 95 95 – 93-95 94-96 – 93-95 94 – –
Guiraud 95-97 92-94+ 94 – 96-97 – 96 96 94-96 95-97 – – 92-94 96 – –
Haut Bages Liberal 94-96 94-96 94 – 95-96 – 93 – 94-96+ – – – 92-94 94 – 93-95
Haut Bailly 94-96 95-97 95 – 97-98 – 97 95 95-97 96-98 96-98 – 96-98 96 – 94-96
Haut Batailley 93-96 93-95 94 – 94-95 – 94 94 93-95 92-94 89-91 – 91-93 92 – 91-93
Haut Brion 95-97 97-99 97 – 98-99 – 98-100 97 96-98 97-99 98-100 – 96-98 98 – 95-97
Haut Brion Blanc 93-96 97-99 95 – 97-98 – 98 95 94-96 97 95-97 – 95-97 97 – 93-94
Issan 93-95 94-96 94 – 96-97 – 95 95 – 94-96 92-94 – 91-93 94 – 93-95
Lafite Rothschild 95-98 96-98+ 98 – 97-98 – 98-100 97 95-97 96-98 97-99 – 95-97 98 – 97-99
Lafleur 93-96 98-100 97 – 98-99 – 98 98 – 97-99 98-100 – 97-99 97 – 98-100
Lafon Rochet 93-95 – 92 – 93-94 – 93 93 – 92-94 91-93 – 91-93 91 – 91-93
Lagrange (Saint Julien) – – 92 – 94-95 – 95 94 93-95+ 91-93 92-94 – 91-93 95 – 93-95
Lagune 92-94 93-95 93 – 94-95 – 93 94 90-92 92-94 88-90 – – 93 – 90-92
Langoa Barton 91-93 92-94+ 92 – 94-95 – 94 92 91-93+ 92-94 90-92 – 91-93 92 – 93-95
Larcis Ducasse 94-96 95-97+ 94 – 96-97 – 95 93 95-97+ 94-96 94-96 – 93-95 94 – 93-95
Lascombes 92-95 94-96+ 95 – 95-96 – 94 94 93-95+ 93-95 93-95 – 92-94 93 – 92-94
Latour 96-98 96-98 97 – 98-99 – 98 98 94-96 97-99 96-98 – 96-98 98 – 94-96
Leoville Barton 93-95 94-96 95 – 96-97 – 97 95 93-95+ 93-95 94-96 – 92-94 95 – 94-96
Leoville Las Cases 94-97 96-98 96 – 97-98 – 98 97 94-97 96-98 95-97 – 95-97 97 – 94-96
Leoville Poyferre 95-97 94-96 95 – 95-96 – 98 96 95-97 95-97 93-95 – 95-97 93 – 93-95
Lynch Bages 94-97 94-96+ 95 – 97-98 – 96 95 95-97 94-96 93-95 – 93-95 95 – 93-95
Malartic Lagraviere 92-94 93-95 93 – 95-96 – 95 91 92-94 92-94 91-93 – 90-92 91 – 91-93
Malescot St Exupery 92-94 92-94 93 – 96-97 – 92 – 92-94 93-95 92-94 – 92-94 92 – 93-95
Margaux 97-100 97-99 100 – 99-100 – 98 97 96-100 98-100 97-99 – 97-99 98 – 95-97
Mission Haut Brion 92-95 96-98 96 – 97-98 – 96 96 96-100 – 96-98 – 93-95 97 – 94-96
Mission Haut Brion Blanc 92-94 96-98 94 – 96-97 – 96 93 94-96 95-97 94-96 – 93-95 97 – 93-95
Monbousquet 91-93 90-92 94 – 94-95 – 89 – 92-94 92-94 91-93 – – 93 – –
Montrose 95-97 98-100 95 – 99-100 – 98 97 97-100 97-99 97-99 – 96-98 96 – 97-100
Mouton Rothschild 96-99 97-99 97 – 98-99 – 98-100 97 96-98 97-99 95-97 – 96-98 98 – 94-96
Ormes Pez 91-93 89-91 93 – 93-94 – 92 91 91-93+ 90-92 86-88 – 91-93 91 – 90-91
Pagodes Cos 92-94 92-94 92 – 93-94 – 93 92 91-94 92-94 80-92 – 90-92 92 – 91-93
Palmer 98-100 96-98 97 – 97-98 – 97 – 96-98 97-99 96-98 – 95-97 96 – 96-97
Pape Clement 95-97 94-96 92 – 97-98 – 93 91 95-97 95-97 93-95 – 93-95 94 – 92-94
Pape Clement Blanc 93-95 93-95 92 – 96-97 – 94 94 91-94 95 93-95 – 91-93 94 – 91-93
Pavie 95-97+ 96-98 98 – 99-100 – 96 – 95-97+ 97-99 98-100 – 95-97 96 – –
Pavie Decesse – – – – – – – – – – – – – – – –
Pavie Macquin 95-97 92-94 94 – 98-99 – 96 95 93-95+ 97-99 95-97 – 94-96 95 – 93-95
Pavillon Blanc 92-94 95-97 93 – 96-97 – 96 95 93-95+ 95 94-96 – 88-90 91 – 93-95
Pavillon Rouge 90-93 92-94 94 – 96-97 – 93 95 91-93+ 92-94 92-94 – 90-92 92 – 92-94
Petit Mouton 93-95 93-95+ 93 – 95-96 – 94 93 93-95 92-94 91-93 – 91-93 92 – 91-93
Petit Village 91-94 94-96+ 94 – 96-97 – 92 92 – 93-95 – – 90-92 94 – 89-91
Petrus 93-96 97-99 98 – 99-100 – 97 98 – 98-100 98-100 – 95-97 98 – 97-99
Phelan Segur 92-94 92-94+ 92 – 96-97 – 90 91 92-94 92-94 92-94 – 92-94 92 – 91-93
Pichon Baron 95-97 95-97 97 – 96-97 – – 97 95-97 96-98 95-97 – 94-96 95 – 95-97
Pichon Lalande 95-98 96-98+ 97 – 98-99 – 98 96 95-97+ 96-98 95-97 – 96-98 96 – 97-99
Pin 96-99 98-100 100 – 99-100 – 97 97 94-96 – 98-100 – 97-99 97 – 94-96
Pontet Canet 94-97 94-96+ 97 – 97-98 – 98-100 – 95-97 95-97 97-99 – 93-95 96 – 96-98
Quinault l’Enclos 91-93 92-94 93 – 94-95 – 93 92 92-94+ 93-95 92-94 – 90-92 92 – 89-91
Quintus 94-96 93-95 94 – 95-96 – 87 95 87-89 – 92-94 – – 93 – 93-95
Rauzan Segla 96-98 95-97 96 – 97-98 – 96 95 93-95+ 96-98 95-97 – 93-95 95 – 94-96
Reserve Comtesse 92-94 92-94 93 – 94-95 – 93 90 91-93 91-93 91-93 – 90-92 92 – 91-93
Rieussec – – – – – – – 95 – – – – 93-95 95 – –
Saint Pierre 93-95 92-94 93 – 94-95 – 95 95 92-95 92-94 93-95 – 91-93 91 – 92-94
Smith Haut Lafitte 95-97 95-97 96 – 98-99 – 96 96 96-98 96-98 94-96 – 94-96 94 – 94-96
Smith Haut Lafitte Blanc 94-96 95-97 95 – 97-98 – 92 95 95-97 – 94-96 – 95-97 96 – 94-96
Sociando Mallet 89-91 92-94 91 – 94-95 – – 93 – 92-94 91-93 – 89-91 92 – 90-92
Suduiraut 98-100 96-98+ 95 – 97-98 – – 96 96-99 97-99 – – 96-98 96 – –
Talbot 93-95 92-94 93 – 94-95 – 94 92 91-93+ 92-94 – – 91-93 92 – 92-94
Tertre 91-93 92-94 92 – 95-96 – 93 92 91-93 91-93 87-89 – – 93 – 92-94
Troplong Mondot 95-98 95-97 96 – 97-98 – 97 – 92-94+ 96-98 96-98 – 95-97 94 – 95-97
Trotanoy 94-97 95-97+ 96 – 97-98 – 95 96 95-97 97-99 95-97 – 93-95 96 – 95-97
Valandraud 94-96 95-97 93 – 97-98 – 95 97 95-97 96-98 94-96 – 95-97 93 – –
Vieux Chateau Certan 96-98 97-99 99 – 97-98 – 96 – 96-98 97-99 97-99 – 94-96 97 – 94-96

Sources

You can find all the webpages of those mentioned in our Bordeaux En Primeur 2022 Critic Scores grid below:

AG = Antonio Galloni (Vinous)

CH = Colin Hay (The Drinks Business)

Falstaff = Falstaff (Falstaff)

GH = Georgina Hindle (Decanter)

JS = James Suckling (James Suckling)

JR = The team at JancisRobinson.com (JancisRobinson.com)

JA = Jane Anson (Inside Bordeaux)

JMQ = Jean-Marc Quarin (Quarin)

JD = Jeb Dunnuck (JebDunnuck.com)

JL = Jeff Leve (The Wine Cellar Insider)

LPB = Lisa Perotti-Brown (The Wine Independent)

MJ = Matthew Jukes (Matthew Jukes)

NM = Neal Martin (Vinous)

RV = Roger Voss (Wine Enthusiast)

WA = William Kelley and Yohan Castaing (Wine Advocate)

The smartest way to price, source and sell wine

Join Liv-ex